Illegal foreclosure documents may vindicate millions of borrowers

Thursday, September 23rd, 2010 By

illegal foreclosure document

A foreclosure document processor at a major mortgage lender authorized the eviction of tens of thousands of homeowners without reading their files. Image: Thinkstock

Foreclosure documents processed by Ally Financial used to repossess homes and evict residents were submitted to courts without verifying their accuracy. A single Ally Financial employee said he signed off on as many as 10,000 foreclosure documents a week without reading them and without a notary present. The revelation led Ally Financial, the fourth-largest mortgage lender in the U.S., to suspend evictions of homeowners in 23 states. Other companies–including Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac–who used Ally Financial to process foreclosure documents may also be affected. The Ally Financial case could give millions of homeowners a stout legal leg to stand on for challenging foreclosure in court.

Foreclosure documents submitted without verification

Some of the nation’s largest mortgage lenders have been accused of foreclosing on families without verifying all the information in a case. The Washington Post reported that in sworn depositions involving families trying to keep their homes, Jeffrey Stephan, head of Ally’s foreclosure document processing team, neither read the documents or signed them in the presence of a notary as required. Stephan would sign up to 10,000 documents a month, which were bundled and sent off for notarization later. The Post said that at the rate Stephan was reviewing files, in an eight-hour day he would have spent an average of 1.5 minutes on each document. The documents were then used in court by law firms, sometimes called “foreclosure mills” to evict homeowners so the bank could sell their properties.

Mortgage lending abuses continue in the courts

Abuses by the mortgage lending industry that led to the housing crisis and foreclosure epidemic are still having an effect. The Wall Street Journal reports that the courts are struggling with complex paperwork on millions of mortgages that have been packaged, chopped up, scrambled and resold to investors as securities. The schemes have made it difficult for courts to identify who actually owns a mortgage. Foreclosure documents are intended to clarify that issue. In the case of Stephan, who has been called a “robo-signor,” and “affadavit slave,” the banks turning the homeowners out on the street don’t really know who owns the loan either.

A legal gift for foreclosed homeowners

Ally Financial’s illegal foreclosure documents may cast doubt over millions of foreclosures filed by Wall Street banks in the past few years. The issue could open the door for homeowners across the country to challenge foreclosure proceedings. Andy Kroll at Mother Jones writes that according to federal rules of civil procedure, affidavits like the kind Stephan was signing “must be made on personal knowledge, set out facts that would be admissible in evidence, and show that the affiant is competent to testify on the matters stated.” To abide by the law, Stephan had to read the documents in detail to know what they said. Before he signed them, he had to be familiar enough with their contents to defend them in court.

Previous Article

« Easy payday loans

"Easy" and "within 2 hours" aren't usually what you think of when you think of loans, but there are easy payday loans of up to $1,500! A worried, stressed man with his hands on his head.
Next Article

Sugarhouse Casino | Dangerous neighbor or badly needed stimulus? »

Philadelphia's Sugarhouse Casino is officially open for business -- but that doesn't mean the debate around the issue is cooling off. Sugarhouse Casino

If you found this article helpful, share it with a friend!

  • maryann marquez

    bank of america took my home with 6 day notice, i applied for home modification sent in all required paper work for months, when we spoke on the phone it was everything is fine, in jan 2011 they said your file is in review, no need to send any more paper work. last week i spoke with someone and they said everything is going ok. 3 days later eviction notice to move out in 6days, how about that bullsh**, i spent all my 401 k savings to upgrade the house as an investment for retirement which will be in 4 years, now i have nothing. well bank of america has 230 classactions against them now its going to be 231

  • Elenita De Lucca

    Are there any class action suits against these criminal banks? This story is all too common and accepted. I was also victimized by the banks and their real estate agents and attorneys although I did everything in my power to work out a loan modification and fight the eviction. My home was put up for a trustee sale while I was negotiating with both my lender and working with a third party/attorneys to modify my loan, I was able to stall the first sale but was never notified that it was immediately rescheduled for sale again then sold. I was devastated, angry, depressed for 2 years. Now I want to fight back legally along with the rest of you. These greedy scum suckers need to pay back all the families who were illegally bulldozed out of their homes for all the pain and suffering. Individual homeowners should have been bailed out, not the banks!

  • Zao

    If the US goverment is powerless with all this illegal foreclosures what we the citizens can do? __In the process of loan modification in CA with lender NationStar Mortgage. Owers received a letter from Nationstar on Thurs Nov.11, 2010 saying "thank you we received your documents. Please note that during this evaluation period, your home will not be referred for forclousure or be sold at a foreclosure sale if the foreclosure process has already initiated" __Next day on Friday Nov 12, 2010 the home was put in auction and sold to Four Points Investments, LLC. __House had equity. Owners were trow out of home of 18 years +. while in the process of loan modification. This is devastating for USA famlies. __

  • D.D.

    Wells Fargo has called us almost every month of the eight months they have held our 8,000,00 home equity loan. Our home is worth 80.000.00, we owe 8.000.00, yet every time we are ONE DAY LATE the calls start. Wells Fargo calls 5-6 times per day, even after speaking to us personally, to harrass us. We live paycheck to paycheck like most people now do and we always pay within 7 days after the due date, well within the "grace period." I have complained numerous times about the repeated calls and have not been able to get Wells Fargo to stop the practice. They claim that the calls are made by computer so they are not responsible for the number of calls per day, even though it is always a "human" rep who speaks to us…several times per day We have been told that by being one day late we are "delinquent" and that the calls are "collection calls." I believe that Wells Fargo is trying to find an excuse to take our home! They are not affraid of the government, but they are affraid of posts like this!

    • DNTD

      Wells Fargo changed the locks on our home last summer. After fighting for two months to at least get our things out we were given exactly four hours to remove whatever we could. After living in a home for 18 years it's kind of hard to empty in 4 hours. This happened after 9 sets of loan modification papers and numerous representatives calling me to say I was pre-approved for a lower payment and there were no problems other than having me sign paperwork I never got. Our house did not sell at a sheriff sale, they just took possession of it and as of yesterday in our local courthouse we are still listed as the owners free and clear without any leins yet they have the house up for sale. The contents we had to leave were piled in a dumpster they parked out front. I get sick when I think of the things they discarded, furniture, pictures, childhood memories, all of it that we couldn't carry in the four hours they were watching the clock. We lost thousands of dollars worth of things even without putting a price tag on the sentimental value of some of it. I am now attempting to retain a lawyer to go after them but finding the money to pay a lawyer is difficult. How can these people sleep at night?

    • DNTD

      We were two hard working professionals who were late one month three years ago, they piled up interest since then and we had no idea what was going on until last winter when we got a foreclosure notice. In our last conversation, the lady at Wells Fargo told me to "get a lawyer" and hung up on me. Memories are gone, our home is gone and it's a shame that things like this are happening all over the United States.

  • brenda

    i had 2 million dollars in property foreclosed, i believe, prematurely and illegally. anyone know of class action law suit. bank of america, wells fargo, aurora, countrywide.

    • Mark

      Better do some research and read cases that are similar to yours. Cases in your state would be best as laws vary. The whole system is riddled with fraud. They all have lawsuits against them of some sort. Fight them even after foreclosure by yourself until you can find legal help if you wish. Stay in the house and respond to the Dispossessory Notice when they file for eviction. You can do this now as Pro Se. Whoever foreclosed on you must be able to produce the "original note" which they probably don't have as lenders sell these to investors over and over. Investors are even suing the banks. Most judges do not understand this process so you may have to educate them after you learn how the scam is working. Don't be afraid of them. They are just greedy evil people with a name title. Good Luck

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1222841782 Chris Dix

    The solution to ensuring a good faith mortgage negotiation is to calculate an unbiased Net Present Value using bank software so that the lender can’t dispute the calculations. The REST Report does exactly that and has been sanctioned by every single judge who has ruled on it. The software always recommends modification or short sale since those solutions benefit the mortgage investor and homeowner the most.